Overview

Nestled in the heart of Bismarck, Illinois, Andi Mae's Ice Cream Shoppe is a delightful destination for anyone craving quality ice cream crafted with care. Located at 17143 E 2750 North Rd, this charming ice cream shop has garnered a loyal following not only locally but also from neighboring states, as customers happily make the journey for its unparalleled flavors.

What sets Andi Mae's apart is its thoughtful range of offerings that go beyond the typical scoop. The shop caters to various tastes and dietary preferences, including no-dairy options like the oat-based “Peanut Buddy” and no-sugar-added flavors such as the cashew and caramel blend. This inclusive approach ensures that everyone, from traditional ice cream lovers to those with dietary restrictions, can find something to savor.

The menu, rich with dozens of unique and inventive flavors, reflects a commitment to both creativity and quality ingredients. Favorites like rhubarb crumble showcase seasonal and homestyle influences, delivering a comforting yet exciting experience. Multiple customers have noted the value they receive here, praising generous portions and friendly, welcoming service that makes every visit memorable.

The atmosphere at Andi Mae's is inviting and relaxed, perfect for families, couples, or solo visitors who want to enjoy a satisfying treat in a cozy setting. The shop resonates particularly well with those who appreciate artisan ice cream made with a personal touch, far from mass-produced alternatives.

Andi Mae's Ice Cream Shoppe is more than just a local stop; for some, it’s worth a deliberate trip from over 20 miles away or even across state lines. This speaks volumes about the quality and care infused in every scoop, making it a must-visit for anyone passionate about superior ice cream experiences.

Whether you’re in Bismarck or passing through the area, a visit to Andi Mae's offers an authentic taste of handcrafted ice cream that satisfies cravings with both flavor and heart.


What Customers Say

Pamela Potts
Feb 16,2026
5/5
We drive from Indiana to enjoy their ice cream! It’s the best around!
Jeanne Jones
Feb 16,2026
5/5
My husband and myself have been recently introduced to Andie Maes ice cream we simply love it! They actually have ice cream that we both really enjoy. He gets the no dairy oat peanut buddy and for myself no sugar added cashew and Carmel...it's very worth the drive and very very friendly service
Vickie Prentice
Feb 16,2026
5/5
This is the BEST ice cream shop ever. Price is right you get a lot for your money. My #1 favorite is rhubarb crumble. . It's pretty far from where I live,BUT it's worth the drive. About 20+ miles away. They have dozens of flavors. What ever you have a craving for. I suggest you too should go here too. Enjoy!!
Michelle H
Feb 16,2026
5/5
Yum! Excellent ice cream place with friendly service.
Dave DelRosario
Feb 16,2026
5/5
Excellent ice cream! As i was visiting from GA i miss these types of places where you can enjoy a cup for what it is and how good it is. Coming back for sure!
Sherri Askren
Feb 16,2026
5/5
It's sooooo very yummy!! So many fantastic flavors and dairy free options, which are impossible to fine, plus the nicest workers ever. It's my go to place for ice cream now
Tickles
Feb 16,2026
5/5
Great employees, great ice cream, great selection. No better place around! They feed everybody here!
Dusty Cowell
Feb 16,2026
5/5
I was out on my motorcycle exploring. I ran across this fun ice cream establishment. The workers were super helpful. The Turtle Sundae was totally worth the ride from Indiana.

Leave a Review

Location

Opening Hours

Updating...
Top Picks for You

More in Bismarck, Illinois, USA

Handpicked spots for food lovers. Your next favorite meal awaits!